IRDAI penalizes Policybazaar ₹5 crore for regulatory violations like biased promotions, premium delays & poor compliance. Here’s what it means for Indian insurance buyers.
What if the insurance plan you bought, thinking it was “the best,” wasn’t actually the best at all?
Imagine trusting a platform to show you top insurance products — only to find out later that their rankings weren’t based on merit, but on behind-the-scenes deals.
That’s the real concern behind the massive ₹5 crore penalty recently imposed by the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) on Policybazaar Insurance Brokers.
This isn’t just a slap on the wrist. It’s a warning shot for India’s booming online insurance sector — and a wake-up call for every consumer who uses these platforms.
In this blog, we’ll break down the key violations, explain what this means for policyholders like you, and explore how the insurance space must evolve to rebuild trust.
🚨 What Did Policybazaar Do Wrong?
1. Biased Product Promotions: The Illusion of “Top Plans”
IRDAI’s biggest concern? Policybazaar labeled certain insurance products as “Top” or “Best” — without clear criteria or comparison tools.
What’s the problem here?
- It gave an unfair advantage to specific insurers.
- Customers were misled into thinking these plans were IRDAI-approved or objectively superior.
- This practice creates false trust in a regulated industry.
For example, only 12 out of 23 health insurance partners were showcased as “Top Plans.” Similarly, in the ULIP section, only 5 insurers were promoted — despite broader partnerships.
Takeaway: Insurance isn’t a one-size-fits-all game. Calling one plan “best” without explaining why is not just misleading — it’s dangerous.
2. Delayed Premium Transfers: A Risky Gap for Customers
The inspection revealed Policybazaar held on to collected premiums, sometimes for over 30 days, before transferring them to insurers.
This is a violation of Section 64VB of the Insurance Act, which requires brokers to transfer premiums within 24 hours.
Why does this matter?
- Delays can lead to policy issuance gaps.
- Consumers may not be covered during this lag.
- If a claim arises in this window, it may be denied — even if you paid on time.
In short: You thought you were insured. You weren’t.
Takeaway: Timely remittance isn’t a backend formality — it’s your lifeline in times of crisis.
3. Opaque Outsourcing and Commissions: Who’s Watching the Watchdogs?
Policybazaar had poorly monitored outsourcing contracts — with high commissions being paid to third-party agencies. The IRDAI found:
- Over 1 lakh telemarketing-driven policies had no verifiable call recordings.
- Policies were not properly mapped to authorized verifiers.
- Some contractual payouts lacked compliance controls.
This raises red flags about transparency, oversight, and customer protection.
Takeaway: If third-party agents are pushing products without accountability, the risk of mis-selling increases exponentially.
4. Governance Violations: Directors in Conflict?
The report also found key managerial personnel (KMPs) at Policybazaar held directorships in other companies — without IRDAI’s permission.
This goes against governance norms meant to prevent conflict of interest and regulatory loopholes.
Takeaway: When leadership flouts oversight, it trickles down into every part of the business.
5. Misuse of Platform Power: Only Few Products Displayed
Policybazaar, as a licensed Insurance Web Aggregator (now a composite broker), is expected to provide neutral, inclusive product listings.
But IRDAI noted that:
- The platform favored certain insurers in its listings.
- Even with multiple insurer tie-ups, only select products were displayed.
- No clear rationale was provided to consumers.
Think of it like an online store showing only 5 brands when it has deals with 20 — just because the top 5 pay more. Would you trust that store again?
Takeaway: Platforms must be bridges between consumers and insurers — not biased gatekeepers.
🧠 What You Should Remember
At the heart of this controversy lies a fundamental truth:
Insurance is a trust-based product. If the recommendation engine itself is biased or broken, consumers lose more than just money — they lose confidence.
The ₹5 crore fine isn’t just about numbers. It’s a loud, regulatory message to the entire industry: Transparency is non-negotiable.
🔍 Why the Penalty Matters: Lessons for the Insurance Ecosystem
For Consumers:
- Don’t blindly trust “Top Plans” or “Best Picks.”
- Always cross-check products directly on the insurer’s official site.
- Ask for documentation, policy terms, and exact coverage details.
For Web Aggregators:
- Maintain objective criteria for rankings.
- Remit premiums promptly — or risk consumer backlash and legal trouble.
- Ensure full disclosure of commissions, tie-ups, and third-party involvement.
For IRDAI:
- This action sets a new standard for digital insurance compliance.
- It signals that the era of unchecked aggregator power is over.
📊 Timeline of Key Events
| Date | Event |
| June 1–5, 2020 | IRDAI inspects Policybazaar operations |
| Oct 7, 2024 | Show Cause Notice issued |
| Feb 2024 | Policybazaar gets composite broker license |
| Aug 4, 2025 | ₹5 crore penalty imposed |
🔍 Real-World Analogy: The Biased College Counsellor
Imagine a career counselor who keeps telling students that only 5 colleges are “the best,” never explaining why, and conveniently earning a commission for each student sent there.
Now imagine students applying, only to find later that better options were intentionally hidden.
That’s how it feels when a web aggregator doesn’t play fair.
❗What Happens Next?
Policybazaar has stated it will present the matter to its board and submit a report to IRDAI detailing remedial steps.
But beyond the corporate clean-up, the real change will come only if digital platforms recalibrate their approach to one that prioritizes consumer protection over conversions.
The penalty is a mirror to the industry — will others look into it or turn away?
🤔 Final Thoughts: The True Cost of Convenience
In today’s digital world, we often trade transparency for speed. We click “Buy Now” on insurance without really knowing:
- Who’s recommending this plan?
- Is there a better fit for my needs?
- Is the platform unbiased?
This case reminds us: Convenience should never come at the cost of clarity.
So the next time you shop for insurance — pause, research, compare, and ask questions.
Because behind every flashy button that says “Top Plan,” there might be more than meets the eye.
📣 Your Turn:
Have you ever felt confused or misled while buying insurance online? Share your experience in the comments — let’s help others buy better, together.
Leave a Reply to Vikram Reddy Cancel reply